David Dodd enters Federal Court. David Dodd was sentenced to 87 months in the federal prison system, ordered to pay more than 20 million dollars in restitution. Dodd was taken in to custody after the close of the hearing .
Dodd family members enter court.
U.S. Attorney Peter Smith. Mr. Dodd is now in custody.
Assistant U.S. Attorney William Behe. He made decisions to come up with this company Industrial Development & Construction, to create these trusts to hide funds.
Peter Smith. A pattern of deceit, and deception, and false statements.
As released by the Office of United States Attorney Peter J. Smith.
NEWS RELEASE  LOCAL BUSINESSMAN SENTENCED TO 87 MONTHS FOR MISAPPROPRIATION OF FEDERAL FUNDS, FRAUD AND MONEY LAUNDERING.
The United States Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Pennsylvania announced that today, Senior U.S. District Court Judge Sylvia H. Rambo today sentenced David R. Dodd, II, age 45, of Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, to 87 months imprisonment for misappropriation of federal funds and money laundering.
Dodd was also ordered to pay restitution totally approximately $21 million to suppliers, sub-contractors, Metro Bank, the City of Harrisburg and Dauphin County.
Assistant U.S. Attorney William A. Behe told the Court that Dodd’s conduct reflected far more than bad judgment. It contained false statements, hidden conflicts of interest and repeated deceptive acts. Senior Judge Rambo agreed to the Government’s request that Dodd be taken into custody by U.S. Marshals immediately after the sentencing.
According to United States Attorney Peter Smith, Dodd pleaded guilty in November 2011. He was charged in two separate indictments returned by federal grand juries in June 2010 and January 2011, both involving fraudulent real estate and business deals associated with the Capital View Commerce Center (CVCC), a failed construction project in Harrisburg.
Dodd utilized a business he owned known as Industrial Design and Construction, Inc. (IDC) as part of the Capital View Commerce Center (CVCC) project to purchase pre-cast concrete forms for use in the construction of the building.
Dodd concealed his own personal interest in IDC in violation of federal conflict of interest requirements and, through that concealment, wrongfully obtained over one million dollars of funds from HUD through programs administered by the City of Harrisburg and Dauphin County. These funds were placed into a brokerage account at Dodd’s direction to conceal the existence and ownership of the misappropriated funds.
Dodd was also paid $860,454 in HUD funds through programs administered by the City of Harrisburg and Dauphin County to pay contractors who performed and completed work on the CVCC project.
Although Dodd, through his business Cameron Real Estate, LP, received that money, Dodd kept the money and did not pay the contractors as he was obligated to do.
After five days of hearings to establish the amount of the loss resulting from Dodd’s conduct, Judge Rambo filed a 37-page opinion on October 15, 2013 awarding $20,943,635.13 in restitution as follows:
H&R Mechanical, $1,255,468.62.
Weaver Glass, $594,890.00.
Stone Fire Protection, $308,755.40.
Scheadler Yesco, $390,767.05.
Stewart-Amos Steel, $622,146.52.
Ciesco, $118,218.11.
Macri Concrete, $323,057.70.
H.W. Nauman, $31,672.47.
Herre Brothers, Inc., $1,265,237.50.
Metro Bank, $9,489,864.88.
Dauphin County, $2,752,450.64.
City of Harrisburg, $3,512,777.70 and $308,328.54.
Victims’ statements were read into the record of the sentencing hearing by the former owner of Herre Brothers, a contractor that went out of business as a result of Dodd’s conduct, and the City of Harrisburg.
Judge Rambo concluded that Dodd was responsible for the projects demise and the loss to the contractors.
As part of the plea agreement with the Government, Dodd agreed to forfeit to the Government $1,151,037 seized from Wells Fargo brokerage accounts, a 2008 BMW X5 vehicle, a 2008 Mercedes Benz and $58,041 in cash.
The joint investigation was conducted by the HUD’s Office of Inspector General, Internal Revenue Service-Criminal Investigations, the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Dauphin County District Attorney’s Office.
The case was prosecuted by Assistant United States Attorney William A. Behe. Support was provided by the U.S. Attorney’s Office Victim Rights and Asset Recovery Unit.
From our Archives.
The Story of David Dodd and the Capitol View Commerce Center:
At 1000 North Cameron Street, at the corner of Cameron and Herr Streets in Harrisburg, a large dilapidated building stands alone in the middle of an overgrown industrial lot. Rusted signs hang outside of the perimeter fence displaying messages such as DANGER. CONSTRUCTION AREA. KEEP OUT and NO LOITERING. Inside the fence, random construction parts lay around the abandoned, half-finished building neglected since the contractors ordered their workers to walk off the site in 2008.
At one time, this now deserted project was hailed as an economic leap for the City of Harrisburg. The 215,000 square foot building, known as the Capitol View Commerce Center, was applauded as a kickstart for the local economy, a job creator, and a new anchor for Cameron Street, a street grossly overlooked in Harrisburg's evolvement to a vibrant and lively city. At least this is what owner and developer David Dodd claimed as he pitched his project to the city and Dauphin County's elected officials, businesses, and residents.
The Capitol View Commerce Center was envisioned to be a place where Dodd's printing company, Advanced Communications, was to have new office space along with a state of the art printing center. Remaining space in the massive Commerce Center would be leased to other companies and businesses. The claim was that the new construction would bring a sense of prosperity to Cameron Street, while providing jobs and spurring positive development to the severely indebted City of Harrisburg. It was a superb dream for Harrisburg, but the reality of the project would be far worse.
The saga of the Capitol View Commerce Center began in 2005 when Dodd managed to convince the City of Harrisburg and Dauphin County to borrow money from the U.S. Housing and Urban Development guaranteed loan program to help fund his project. Dodd persuaded the city to borrow $3.7 million and Dauphin County to borrow $3 million. A letter to the State of Pennsylvania from Mayor Reed made a $5 million grant available to Dodd and his companies. City and County officials were more than willing to help Dodd acquire the money for this project because not only would the project stimulate economic development in the region, but also because Dodd was a well known businessman and his printing company, Advanced Communications, had been in the city for several years.
To further support the project, Mayor Stephen Reed granted Dodd a $240,000 loan from the Mayor's Office of Economic Development (MOED) program. Created by former Mayor Reed, MOED loans were a way to help businesses in and out of the city to start up and maintain their establishments.
On January 2, 2006, the Central Penn Business Journal reported that Dodd and Advanced Communications had already received $9.4 million in grants and loans from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and from the City of Harrisburg to start the project. It was claimed the construction would take ten months. Dodd stated, "I think it’s going to be quite a facelift for Cameron Street."
At the time, Dodd would not elaborate on where he would obtain enough funds to meet the estimated complete $28 million cost of construction. Though it was unknown at the time, this lack of detail was the start of the process of Capitol View Commerce Center's financial collapse.
By June 2008, all construction on the Capitol View Commerce Center stopped as the contractors told their employes to walk off the site. Contractors on the project filed liens seeking payment of $3.3 million from Cameron Real Estate LP, listed as the owner of the center in documents filed in Dauphin County Courthouse.
Contractors who filed liens against Cameron Real Estate are Herre Bros, Inc, Weaver's Glass and Building Specialties of Harrisburg, H&R Mechanical of Middletown, and Joseph Stong Inc. Fire Protection of Chester.
As the court case would later reveal, the only contractor who had been paid was Industrial Design & Construction Inc. The precast concrete contractor received $3.5 million for work on the Capitol View Commerce Center.
Industrial Design & Construction Inc. had a single shareholder, an asset protection trust called the Private Ventures Trust. The only beneficiary of the trust was David Dodd, meaning that all the money would have gone directly to him.
For a year, the project seemed completely lost. Then, on January 1, 2009, it was reported that Jacob Frydman, a New York City Investor also pursuing a deal for a long-term lease of Harrisburg's public parking facilities, was interested in buying the abandoned Capitol View Commerce Center. It was speculated that Frydman would only make the purchase if the building was completely pre-leased to the Commonwealth of PA; however, it seems no such deal was ever made. On January 9, 2009, Frydman announced he was not going to buy the Commerce Center.
After many lawsuits had been filed against him, on August 13, 2009 David Dodd filed for bankruptcy. A separate filing was also made ofor Cameron Management Inc., of which Dodd was listed as president. The filing was a Chapter 7 bankruptcy in the Middle District of Pennsylvania U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Harrisburg.
Dodd's bankruptcy hearing was scheduled to happen on September 1, 2009. However, instead of answering questions for his creditors, Dodd's lawyer, Robert Chernicoff of Cunningham & Chernicoff, PC, used the hearing to see if the media would be allowed to sit in on the interrogation. Chernicoff tried to bar the media from being in the courtroom, threatening to walk out with his client if members of The Patriot-News and The Central Penn Business Journal were allowed to stay and report on the hearing.
Dodd's examination was then delayed when the Patriot News and the Central Penn Business Journal objected to the questioning being closed to the media and the public. It was postponed to a later date.
On September 8, 2009, Dodd released a three page statement to the Patriot News blaming everybody except himself for why the Capitol View Commerce Center had failed. As published in the Patriot News, Dodd defended the decision to use Industrial Design & Construction and the payments it received. “All work was done at or below market, and we did everything we possibly could to find an outside contractor before being forced to seek a direct supplier,” Dodd wrote. “No entity that Dodd owns, or Dodd himself, received anything from IDC except for minimal rent for storage space.”
Dodd laid the blame of the failed project on the subcontractors, the city requirements and government processes. According to him, some business did not provide him with the certifications and documents that were required by the city. Dodd asserted that the city issued a directive telling him to stop paying contractors because of that precise lack of documentation. The government was at fault, according to Dodd, for being too slow when it came to payments because the processing took too long. By filing the mechanics liens against his businesses, the subcontractors added even more to the problem. Since the subcontractors filed the liens, Dodd claimed that the entities funding the project considered this to be a default, and thus, stopped paying.
“It was an impossible scenario,” Dodd wrote.
Unfortunately for Dodd and the City of Harrisburg, this “scenario” has created at least 20 mechanics liens, four bankruptcy filings, at least one civil lawsuit and an investigation by the HUD’s inspector general.
Over the next three years, many events occurred to further destroy the image of the once promising David Dodd.
On June 17, 2010, the Thompson Administration reviewed the lost revenues from the project and the figure was, in Mayor Linda Thompson's words, “astonishing.” According to the Thompson Administration, the Capitol View Commerce Center would have generated $13,000 annually in tax revenues had Dodd not defaulted. If the project had been finished and met the original assessed value, those revenues would have been nearly $800,000.
"The schools, the county, everybody has lost something they were promised," Thompson told The Patriot News, "The city alone should get over $100,000 from the building each year, and instead we get $9.50 and the man doesn’t even pay that. Shameful.”
A few months later, a court motion revealed that Dodd made false statements during his meeting with creditors and in his bankruptcy schedules and statements. It was also alleged that Dodd acted to conceal his assets.
Then, only two days after that motion was filed, the IRS seized $1.2 million from Dodd's personal and business accounts. $16,510 was seized from his Hampden Township residence, while $1.15 million was seized from brokerage accounts maintained by Wells Fargo Advisors in the name of Industrial Design and Construction Inc., the only contractor that had been fully paid by Dodd. The court document confirmed that the only shareholder of IDC was Private Ventures Trust and that Dodd was the settler and sole beneficiary.
One year later, on January 5, 2011, a grand jury indictment revealed that Dodd was newly charged with bankruptcy fraud, wire fraud and engaging in financial transactions with proceeds of illegal activity.
Additionally, the counts revealed grand jury findings that Dodd illegally sold two commercial printing presses he used as collateral in 2002 to help obtain a $1.1 million loan from PNC Bank for a real estate deal in Penbrook.
At the time of the sale, Dodd represented to the buyer he owned the presses "free and clear." Dodd, according to the indictment, also did not report the sale to PNC and hid the sale from trustees and creditors in a subsequent bankruptcy filing.
All this new information about Dodd seemed to come to a conclusion on November 15, 2011 when Dodd plead guilty to the federal charges involving the failed Capitol View Commerce Center. The plead could send Dodd to prison for decades. Dodd is required to forfeit roughly $1.15 million in assets.
Sentencing for Dodd had been scheduled for January 20, 2012. However, that sentencing was delayed and has yet to be rescheduled.
Aside from millions owned to creditors and contractors as well as state and federal governments, the Thompson Administration claims David Dodd and Cameron Real Estate owe over $300,000 to the city for the MOED loan No payments have ever been made. Per Dauphin County records, the County gave Dodd a $3 million loan that has never been paid either as well as a $1.5 million grant.
On October 31, 2012 Federal Judge Sylvia Rambo began to hear testimony during a restitution hearing. While parties realize they will most likely never be made whole, many are hoping to ultimately see a return on some of the funds lost to Dodd. Dodd is scheduled to testify on behalf of himself on Monday, November 5th at 9:00am. It is expected that Dodd could be on the stand for the majority of they day.
by Elizabeth DeKok and Tara Leo Auchey
Photo by Natalie Cake